I Know What to Do. So Why Am I Not Doing It?

I Know What to Do. So Why Am I Not Doing It?

You’ve thought about it. You’ve probably researched it. You may even have a beautifully colour-coded plan for it. You know what you need to do. So why aren’t you doing it?

This is one of the most frustrating places to find yourself, particularly if you’re someone who is normally capable, intelligent and good at getting things done. You can solve problems. You make decisions. Other people come to you for answers. You’ve handled difficult situations before. And yet there’s this thing.

The conversation you need to have.
The boundary you need to set.
The project you need to start.
The decision you need to make.
The habit you want to change.
The application you keep meaning to submit.
The thing you need to stop doing.

You know. You just… aren’t doing it. And that can lead to a particularly unhelpful conclusion: What is wrong with me? Probably nothing.

The problem is that we often assume that knowing what to do should automatically result in doing it. Human behaviour simply isn’t that straightforward. Knowing and doing are different things Information is useful. But information alone rarely creates lasting behavioural change. If it did, most of us would sleep eight hours a night, exercise regularly, never procrastinate, always have the difficult conversation promptly and stop scrolling when we said we were going to. We generally know quite a lot about what would be good for us. The interesting question isn’t always: “What should I do?” Sometimes it’s: “What is getting between knowing and doing?” I call this the Knowing–Doing Gap. And the gap can contain all sorts of things.

Fear.
Habit.
Overwhelm.
Perfectionism.
Stress.
Conflicting priorities.
Executive functioning.
Previous experiences.
Identity.
Emotional associations.
A need for certainty.
Avoidance of discomfort.
Or simply a strategy that once served you very well but no longer does.

That last one is important. Your behaviour usually makes sense somewhere We can be incredibly quick to label behaviour as bad.
Bad habits.
Poor motivation.
Self-sabotage.
Laziness.

I’m much more interested in asking: What is this behaviour doing for you? Procrastination might temporarily remove pressure. Perfectionism might protect you from criticism. Avoiding a conversation might protect a relationship — at least in the short term. Keeping yourself relentlessly busy might mean you never have to stop long enough to notice how exhausted or dissatisfied you are. Doing everything yourself might once have been the reason you became successful. The behaviour may now be creating problems, but that doesn’t mean it appeared for no reason. Sometimes change starts not with fighting the behaviour, but with becoming curious about it. “But I’m an intelligent person. I understand all of this.”

Exactly.

And sometimes that makes being stuck even more irritating. Intelligent, capable people can become very good at trying to think their way out of everything. Another podcast. Another book. Another strategy. Another plan. Another beautifully reasoned explanation of why they behave as they do. Insight can be enormously valuable. But understanding a pattern and changing a pattern aren’t necessarily the same thing. You can understand perfectly well why you respond in a particular way and still find yourself responding that way. That’s because behaviour isn’t driven solely by conscious thought. Habits become automatic. Emotions influence decisions. Our bodies learn associations. Stress changes how we respond. Familiar patterns become efficient. We anticipate discomfort and avoid it, sometimes before we’ve consciously realised that’s what we’re doing. So occasionally the answer isn’t more insight. It’s doing something different with the insight you already have. Sometimes the strategy that made you successful becomes the problem.

This is particularly interesting in people who are used to performing at a high level.

Perhaps you’ve built a career by pushing through. You became the reliable one. You coped. You solved things. You worked harder. You took responsibility. You held everything together. Those strategies may have served you extremely well for years. Until they don’t. Suddenly pushing harder creates exhaustion rather than results. Taking responsibility for everything becomes overwhelming. High standards become paralysis. Independence becomes an inability to ask for help. That doesn’t mean you’ve suddenly become less capable. It may mean the conditions have changed while your strategy hasn’t. The question then isn’t: “How do I make myself try harder?” It might be: “Is the way I’ve always done this still the way I want to do it?”

The gap is where the useful work is When someone tells me, “I know what I need to do,” I’m interested. Because we probably don’t need to spend an hour telling them what they already know. I’m more interested in what happens next. What happens when you imagine actually doing it? What do you notice? What thought appears? What feeling shows up? What are you avoiding? What would change if you succeeded? What would you have to give up? What does the current behaviour give you? What are you protecting? And what would make the new behaviour easier rather than simply demanding more willpower? Sometimes those questions lead to straightforward practical changes. Sometimes they uncover beliefs or patterns. Sometimes the work is around stress or emotional regulation. Sometimes it’s about identity. Sometimes we need to experiment with behaviour. And sometimes talking and thinking aren’t enough. That’s why I don’t work from a single technique My work combines coaching and behavioural change with a wider toolkit that can include approaches such as hypnosis, EFT, NLP and other evidence-informed or experiential techniques where they are appropriate. You don’t need to arrive knowing which one you need. In fact, I’d rather you didn’t. You bring the thing you want to change. We work out what’s keeping it in place. And then we choose the most useful way of working with it. For one person that might be a challenging coaching conversation. For another it might be a practical behavioural experiment. For someone else we might work with an emotional or automatic response rather than continuing to analyse it.

The tool isn’t the starting point. You are.

If you’re stuck, try changing the question Instead of: “Why can’t I just make myself do this?” Try: “What is making this difficult to do?” There’s a subtle but important difference. The first question assumes there’s something deficient about you. The second gives you something to investigate. And curiosity gives us far more room to work than criticism. So if you’re an intelligent, capable person thinking: “I know what to do. Why am I not doing it?” perhaps you don’t need another answer. Perhaps it’s time to explore the gap between what you know and what you actually do. Because knowing matters. But change happens in what comes next.

____

Teresa Harris Boag Executive Coach & Behavioural Change Specialist ETCH – Elevate Training, Coaching & Hypnosis

Previous
Previous

The Stories That Shape Us

Next
Next

Emotional Regulation, Behaviour and the Teenage Brain: Why Schools Need a Neuroscience-Informed Approach